Analysis
Seven Pay Commissions: A History of Bhutan's Public Pay
From a minimum government salary of Nu 200 a month in 1974 to the Seventh Pay Commission of 2026, Bhutan has revised public pay more than a dozen times. The record shows a pattern: each revision steps pay up and usually favours the lowest grades, each commission's general revision costs more than the last, and prices then wear the gain down until the next.
13 November 2026 · 9 min read
On this page · 5 sections
Bhutan’s modern civil service, with its pay scales, grades and allowances, was built within a single working lifetime, and its pay has been rebuilt many times along the way.
The Seventh Pay Commission, constituted with effect from 1 October 2026, is the latest step in that record. The earlier ones explain much of what it inherits. The whole record is also set out in one scroll in Seven Pay Commissions in One Picture.
Before the Constitution: revisions by government order
| Year | What changed |
|---|---|
| 1974 | Pay raised by Nu 50–100 a month for all; minimum pay fixed at Nu 200 a month; dearness allowance merged into pay |
| 1988 | The consolidated pay system: most allowances abolished and folded into salary; staff to arrange their own housing; about Nu 138 million a year added to the bill |
| 1996, 1997, 1999 | Three revisions in four years: in 1996, 82% at the lowest grades and 30% at the top; a flat 20% in 1997; in 1999, 25% at the lower levels and 20% above |
| 2005 | 45%, paid as a salary allowance |
| 2006 | The Position Classification System: the P, S and O grades still used today, with P5 as the lowest graduate entry grade; the new scale stood at least 52% above the 1999 scale, absorbing the 2005 allowance |
Before 2008, there was no constitutional body for pay; revisions came through government committees and orders. The 2008 Constitution changed that. Article 30 created an autonomous Pay Commission, to be constituted from time to time on the Prime Minister’s recommendation, which makes its recommendations “with due regard to the economy of the Kingdom”.
Seven commissions
| Commission | Formed | Chair | Recommended | What was enacted | Annual cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First | Aug 2008 | — | about 40–77%, by level | a flat 35% from January 2009 | about Nu 1.3 bn (the commission’s own proposal: Nu 2.3 bn) |
| (2011 allowance) | — | Ministry of Finance notification | — | a lump-sum allowance, reported as 20% across the board (about 15% of the 2009 scale) | — |
| Second | Nov 2013 | Dasho Chhewang Rinzin, MD, Druk Green Power | 20% plus a new house rent allowance | 19–25% from July 2014 (folding in the 2011 allowance), plus a 20% house rent allowance | about Nu 1.8 bn (commission estimate) |
| Third | Feb 2017 | Nim Dorji, Finance Secretary | 40% for local government members | local government only, from July 2017 | about Nu 135 m |
| Fourth | Jan 2019 | Dasho Penjore, Governor, Royal Monetary Authority | 14–29% (14–21% for civil-service grades) | 6–35% from July 2019 (12–24% for civil-service grades), weighted to the lowest grades | about Nu 4.5 bn |
| Fifth | Oct 2022 | Dasho Ugen Chewang, former DHI Chairperson | the “clean wage” structure, with a one-off 3% indexation and a fixed payment | Pay Structure Reform Act 2022: 5% indexation plus a fixed payment | about Nu 0.7 bn as recommended; about Nu 1 bn as enacted |
| Sixth | Feb 2023 | Dasho Ugen Chewang | 50% of minimum pay as a lump sum | Pay Revision Act 2023: 55–74% in total from July 2023 | about Nu 6 bn |
| Seventh | Oct 2026 | Dasho Chhewang Rinzin, MD, Druk Green Power | report due for the winter session | — | — |
What a graduate was paid
The clearest single thread through these revisions is what a new graduate earned on appointment.
| Year | Basic pay at entry | What a graduate received each month |
|---|---|---|
| 2003 | Nu 7,000 (after a probation year at Nu 5,800) | Nu 7,000 |
| 2009 | Nu 14,460 | Nu 14,460 |
| 2011 | Nu 14,460 | Nu 16,602, with the lump-sum allowance |
| 2014 | Nu 17,495 | about Nu 21,000, with house rent allowance |
| 2019 | Nu 20,645 | Nu 24,775, with house rent allowance |
| 2023 | Nu 20,645 | Nu 37,630 with house rent allowance; about Nu 40,600 with all regular monthly items |
Converted into today’s prices, the same figures tell a sharper story:
Real starting pay rose by half between 2003 and 2009. It then drifted slightly down through three revisions, so that by 2019 a graduate was paid a little less in real terms than in 2009. The 2023 revision lifted it to the highest level in this series, and three years of inflation have since brought it back to about the 2009 level.
Five patterns in the record
1. Revisions step up; prices wear down. No revision has yet delivered automatic adjustment between rounds. Annual indexation was recommended in 2019 and deferred, and the 2022 indexation was a one-off. Pay steps up, then erodes until the next round. Since 2009, general civil-service revisions have come two to five years apart.
2. The lowest grades usually get the largest percentage. In 2014 the operational grades received 25% and the executives 19%. In 2019 the range ran from 6% for the Prime Minister and ministers to 35% for elementary service personnel. In 2023 it was 55% at the top and up to 74% at the bottom. Since the 1990s, every graded revision has given the lower grades the larger percentage; the rest were flat. The 1988 consolidation, which by a later Kuensel account gave the largest increases to the senior grades, was the exception.
3. Governments have reshaped what commissions proposed. The First Commission recommended 40–77% and the government enacted a flat 35%. The Fourth recommended 14–29% and the government enacted 6–35%, shifting more to the lower grades. The Constitution allows for this: a commission recommends, and the Lhengye Zhungtshog and Parliament decide.
4. Each commission-led general revision has cost more than the one before. The 2009 revision cost about Nu 1.3 billion a year, the 2014 revision about Nu 1.8 billion, the 2019 revision about Nu 4.5 billion, and the 2023 revision about Nu 6 billion. (The 2011 allowance, added without a commission, cost about Nu 0.6 billion.) The public pay bill more than doubled between 2018-19 and 2024-25. The Bill looks at what that means for the budget.
5. The structure keeps changing as well as the level. The 1988 reform folded allowances into pay; 2014 added a house rent allowance; the 2022 “clean wage” reform cut through more than thirty kinds of allowance, removing some and folding most of the rest into a single variable component. That is why the 2023 increase sits in variable pay while basic pay at P5 has stayed at Nu 20,645 since 2019. The same reform approved a performance-based incentive that, as of October 2026, has not yet been paid.
What the Seventh inherits
The Seventh Pay Commission starts with a chair who has done this before. Dasho Chhewang Rinzin led the Second Commission in 2013, also as head of Druk Green Power. Two of its members sat on recent commissions too. It inherits a graduate salary that has lost about a tenth of its value since July 2023, an exodus that has slowed but not stopped, a pay bill that takes more than half of current spending, and a question that has been open since 2019: whether pay should move between revisions, rather than wait for the next one.
Every commission so far has answered the same constitutional question with the numbers of its own day: what public servants need, weighed against what the economy can carry. The numbers for this round are in the rest of the series.
Sources
- Kuensel — Seventh Pay Commission starts work, report due in two months (10 October 2026; sequence of commissions)
- Kuensel — Pay of government servants increased (1974)
- Kuensel — Pay revision should come with a 'wow' factor: PM (2019; history of revisions 1988–2014)
- Ministry of Finance — Clarification on the recent Pay Revision Order (1 April 2009; the 35% allowance)
- Ministry of Finance — Pay Revision Notification (January 2011)
- Ministry of Finance — Civil Service Pay Scale Order 2014
- Kuensel — Seven-member pay commission formed (2013)
- BBS — Third pay commission formed (21 February 2017)
- Kuensel — Govt proposes 40 percent pay rise for LG officials (2017; Nu 135 million a year)
- Kuensel — Consolidated pay takes effect from March 1 (1988)
- Royal Civil Service Commission — milestones (Position Classification System, 2006)
- Royal Civil Service Commission — Bhutan Civil Service Rules and Regulations 2002 (pay scales as on 1 January 2002)
- The Bhutanese — Government clears road to formation of a pay commission (2013; cost of the 2009 and 2011 revisions)
- Kuensel — Hydropower revenue benefits only 5 percent of population, says NC (2019; First Pay Commission estimate)
- Ministry of Finance — National Budget Report FY2019-20 (Nu 4.53 bn provision for the 2019 revision)
- Kuensel — The cost of pay hike (2014)
- Ministry of Finance — Pay Structure Reform & Pay Revision Notification (July 2023)
- Ministry of Finance — Annual Financial Statements FY2018-19 and FY2024-25 (the pay bill)
- Business Bhutan — No financial performance incentives paid to civil servants under MaX system (10 October 2026)
- World Bank — Consumer price index, Bhutan (FP.CPI.TOTL), for prices before 2013
- National Statistics Bureau — Consumer Price Index, monthly, to September 2026
- Report of the Fourth Pay Commission (April 2019)
- Business Bhutan — Endorsed pay revision still with huge disparities (2019)
- Report of the Fifth Pay Commission (October 2022)
- Report of the Sixth Pay Commission (11 May 2023)
- Kuensel — Public servants set to receive substantial salary hike as pay bill passes (4 July 2023)
- Business Bhutan — Seventh Pay Commission constituted: PM (10 October 2026)